Top Career

Careers, Top Tier

Leadership Tracks

Client seeks removal of consulting firm employee

By Olivia Thomas ·
Consultant at office desk.
Consultant at office desk.

Ananya Rao, a principal consultant at StratEdge Consulting, has been working on the firm’s largest account, Tavora Group, for 14 months. Tavora contributes 25% of StratEdge’s annual revenue. Recently, Tavora’s chief operating officer requested that Ananya be replaced, describing her as “combative” and “difficult to work with.”

Internally, Ananya’s performance reviews are consistently strong, and her engagement leads describe her as sharp and prepared. However, Karan Mehra, the partner who leads the account, acknowledges that Ananya has a direct style and does not soften her views when she believes a client’s approach is wrong.

Two months ago, Ananya told Tavora’s leadership that a restructuring plan they favored would not deliver the expected savings. The client did not take kindly to her assessment, but the numbers have since borne her out. Despite this, Tavora’s dissatisfaction deserves serious attention, as consulting engagements depend on trust, communication, and collaboration.

Read Also: Companies Must Cultivate Future Leaders Proactively

Assessing the Situation

HR has been asked to determine the best course of action. StratEdge must decide whether to move Ananya off the Tavora account, treating the client’s request as a commercial decision, or resist the request, defending the professional independence of its consultants. There may also be a gender dimension, as assertiveness in women can sometimes be perceived differently from similar behavior in men.

Reassignment is not necessarily a punishment, but its consequences for the employee’s reputation, performance assessment, and career progression need to be considered. The precedent matters, as consultants may become more cautious about expressing professional disagreement if they believe it could cost them an assignment.

Kashish Kapoor, global CHRO at Newgen Software, suggests that leaders need to distinguish honest dissent from unacceptable behavior and examine their own biases in the process.

An HR leader recommends a structured approach, including understanding the client’s concerns, giving the employee an opportunity to share her perspective, and reviewing interactions and performance history to establish whether there is a genuine behavioral issue.

Read Also: Birlasoft shifts focus to skills deployment

Considering the Options

One option is to move Ananya to another account, explaining the commercial rationale to her and ensuring that the reassignment does not adversely affect her career. Another option is to decline the client’s immediate request and work towards repairing the relationship. Alternatively, StratEdge could seek specific examples from Tavora, give Ananya a fair hearing, and independently assess her conduct before deciding on the best course of action.

Karan Mehra acknowledges that Ananya has a direct style, which may have contributed to the client’s perception of her as “combative” and “difficult to work with.” However, the accuracy of her advice does not necessarily establish that the manner in which she communicated it was appropriate.

StratEdge must establish whether the complaint concerns Ananya’s conduct, the substance of her advice, or a combination of the two.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© 2026 Top Career. All rights reserved.

Powered by WordPress & Zuzuthemes Willow